Chess Association of Western Australia

2009 WA Open - 7 Rounds

Played at Applecross Senior High School on 21/22 & 28/29 March

Applecross Senior High School was the setting for the new WA Open tournament, and we thank the school for allowing us to use their excellent venue. Unfortunately, a number of our stronger players were missing from the field, including Stephanus Kurniawan, Michael Horstmann, Tim Hare, Tom Donaldson, Yita Choong, David Ellis and myself, and only 23 players ended up taking part. However, with less than a week to go, I had only 9 entries so, from my point of view, the final result is not so bad! Rightly, or wrongly, I choose to believe that we were the victims of multiple coincidences, not a general lack of interest in the event. Anyway, one advantage of having so many strong players absent was that the battle for the 3 qualifying places for the WA Closed Championship was thrown wide open, and we saw a very interesting struggle for those places.

The tournament proved to be a close affair all the way, with Tristan Boyd, Dennis Holland, Marc Vlietstra, Edik Gilmetdinov and Derek Elkington sharing the lead at various stages. Although Tristan did not have things go totally his way, he was never out of the lead and managed to finish just in front, conceding just two draws (Marc Vlietstra & Edik Gilmetdinov). Dennis Holland had an excellent result, losing only to Tristan, and would have finished equal first if he had been able to find a way to win against Eddy Seah in the last round. Marc Vlietstra’s loss to Dennis in round 6 ended his chances of winning but he played some good Chess throughout. Edik Gilmetdinov and Derek Elkington each had amazing tournaments, achieving high scores against strong fields. Eddy Seah and Guy Booth both started slowly but fought their way back to finish equal fourth. Guy managed three consecutive wins against higher rated opponents.

The 3 qualifying places for the WA Closed Championship were taken by Tristan Boyd, Dennis Holland and Marc Vlietstra. Since Tristan is certain to qualify by virtue of his rating, Edik Gilmetdinov will take his qualifying place. If Marc ends up qualifying by rating, then Derek Elkington will also get a qualifying place.

Dennis Holland won his second WA Reserves Championship by a clear point. Veronica Williams won her second WA Womens Championship (by scaring off all challengers?). Aaron McHugh and William Williams each won their respective rating groups the hard way, by winning their last two games.

There were many interesting struggles, and the lower rated players did not always come off second best. The following players each managed to defeat an opponent rated more than 200 points above themselves: Aaron McHugh (twice!!), Peter Zylstra, Grant Bultman, Guy Booth and Edik Gilmetdinov. Also worthy of mention are the four players who drew with an opponent more than 400 points above them: Edik Gilmetdinov (against Tristan Boyd!), Gary Donaldson, Steve Mijailovic and Veronica Williams.

I believe that the event was a success, there seemed to be a good spirit amongst the players, and the two games a day seemed quite comfortable. The possibility of qualifying for the WA Closed Championship added an extra dimension. I would like to repeat the experiment next year and then assess its success. Any comments on the format of the WA Open would be appreciated.

Haydn Barber, DOP

2009 WA Open PGN

Prize Winners

Open:            1st  Tristan Boyd       6.0  (2009 WA Open Champion)
                 2nd  Dennis Holland     5.5
                 3rd  Marc Vlietstra     5.0
Reserves:        1st  Dennis Holland     5.0  (2009 WA Reserves Champion)

Women:           1st  Veronica Williams  2.0  (2009 WA Womens Champion)

U1850/U1700:    =1st  Edik Gilmetdinov   4.5
                      Derek Elkington    4.5
                      Guy Booth          4.5

U1400:           1st  Aaron McHugh       4.0

U1200:           1st  William Williams   3.0

Biggest Upsets:  1st  Aaron McHugh
                 2nd  Peter Zylstra

Final Standings

Place Name               Loc  Score M-Buch. Progr.

  1   Boyd, Tristan      2272 6        21.5   24.5
  2   Holland, Dennis    1837 5.5      19.5   22.5
  3   Vlietstra, Marc    2013 5        21.0   21.0
 4-7  Gilmetdinov, Edik  1699 4.5      21.5   22.0
      Elkington, Derek   1689 4.5      20.5   21.0
      Seah, Eddy         1917 4.5      19.0   16.5
      Booth, Guy         1511 4.5      18.0   17.0
8-11  Dempster, Dave     1772 4        20.0   16.5
      Abdat, Akef        1867 4        19.5   17.0
      Dunlop, Gordon     1845 4        15.5   15.0
      McHugh, Aaron      1360 4        14.5   12.5
 12   Shaw, Robin        1739 3.5      18.0   16.0
13-18 Tomic, Nedeljko    1746 3        20.0   16.0
      Mijailovic, Steve  1399 3        18.0   11.0
      Donaldson, Gary    1394 3        17.0   12.0
      Sam, Ryan          1578 3        14.5   11.0
      McMahon, Denis     1561 3        14.0   10.5
      Williams, William  1144 3        13.0    6.0
19-20 Bultman, Grant     1614 2.5      21.0   11.5
      Williams, Veronica 1122 2.5      15.0    8.0
21-23 Leeson, Robert     1332 2        18.5    7.5
      Zylstra, Peter     1048 2        15.0   10.0
      Murphy, Justin     1352 2        15.0    6.0

Cross Table

No  Name               Loc  Total  1    2    3    4    5    6    7  

1.  Boyd, Tristan      2272 6     12:W  8:W  6:W  2:D 10:D 11:W 15:W
2.  Vlietstra, Marc    2013 5     13:W  7:D  3:W  1:D  8:W  6:L  5:W
3.  Seah, Eddy         1917 4.5   14:W 10:L  2:L 20:W 12:W  7:W  6:D
4.  Abdat, Akef        1867 4     15:W  9:W 11:L  8:L  7:D 16:W 10:D
5.  Dunlop, Gordon     1845 4     16:D 12:L 17:D 19:W 18:W  8:W  2:L
6.  Holland, Dennis    1837 5.5   17:W 23:W  1:L 12:W 11:W  2:W  3:D
7.  Dempster, Dave     1772 4     18:W  2:D 10:L 17:W  4:D  3:L 13:W
8.  Tomic, Nedeljko    1746 3     19:W  1:L 13:W  4:W  2:L  5:L 18:L
9.  Shaw, Robin        1739 3.5   20:W  4:L 14:W   :D 15:L 17:W 11:L
10. Gilmetdinov, Edik  1699 4.5   21:W  3:W  7:W 11:D  1:D 15:L  4:D
11. Elkington, Derek   1689 4.5   22:W 16:W  4:W 10:D  6:L  1:L  9:W
12. Bultman, Grant     1614 2.5    1:L  5:W 23:W  6:L  3:L 18:L 17:D
13. Sam, Ryan          1578 3      2:L 19:W  8:L 15:L 20:W 23:W  7:L
14. McMahon, Denis     1561 3      3:L 21:W  9:L 22:D 17:L 19:W 16:D
15. Booth, Guy         1511 4.5    4:L 20:D 16:W 13:W  9:W 10:W  1:L
16. Mijailovic, Steve  1399 3      5:D 11:L 15:L 21:W 22:W  4:L 14:D
17. Donaldson, Gary    1394 3      6:L 22:W  5:D  7:L 14:W  9:L 12:D
18. McHugh, Aaron      1360 4      7:L   :D 20:D 23:W  5:L 12:W  8:W
19. Murphy, Justin     1352 2      8:L 13:L 21:W  5:L 23:L 14:L   :W
20. Leeson, Robert     1332 2      9:L 15:D 18:D  3:L 13:L   :W 21:L
21. Williams, William  1144 3     10:L 14:L 19:L 16:L   :W 22:W 20:W
22. Williams, Veronica 1122 2.5   11:L 17:L   :W 14:D 16:L 21:L 23:W
23. Zylstra, Peter     1048 2       :W  6:L 12:L 18:L 19:W 13:L 22:L